
The gospel reading for this Sunday is one of my favorites. In Matthew 18:15-17, we hear Jesus say,
“If your brother or sister sins against you, go and point out the fault when the two of you are alone. If you are listened to, you have regained that one. But if you are not listened to, take one or two others along with you, so that every word may be confirmed by the evidence of two or three witnesses. If that person refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church, and if the offender refuses to listen even to the church, let such a one be to you as a gentile and a tax collector.”
A reflection by Danny Schweers for September 6, 2026.
Unlike the parables, which are stories, here Jesus is laying out for us clear directions to govern our behavior when we have a grievance with someone. And, unlike his admonitions elsewhere in the Bible to simply forgive those who trespass against us, here Jesus gives us three steps to take before deciding to keep away from the other person.
In my experience, most people skip the first two steps and immediately go to step three. Instead of trying to reconcile themselves to the person who angered them, they try to get others angry, try to get others to take their side in the disagreement. They complain to others and avoid saying anything to the person who offended them.
If someone comes to me with a grievance, I often ask if they have met with the person who has done them wrong, if they have tried to resolve the issue. I cannot remember ever being told yes. Usually the person complaining is nursing their hurt rather than doing the hard work of reconciliation. Complaining is easy and gratifying. We are looking for confirmation that, yes, justice is on our side and our feelings of anger are justified.
It is hard work to seek reconciliation by meeting one-on-one, harder still to arrange mediation with a few others, harder still to ask the help of all.
One of my friends in church is a professional mediator. When I can get him to open up, his stories are quite entertaining about people bringing their grievances before him. Often the stories are accounts of overly-sensitive feelings and stubbornness to admit fault, stories about conflicts with easy solutions except for the indignant self-righteousness of the parties involved.
Even if all three steps fail to bring reconciliation, the punishment to the offender is to shun them, not burn them at the stake or to otherwise do them harm. Even then, shunning should not rule out reconciliation. Sin is about separation and shunning acknowledges that separation, hoping always for reunion. Sin separates us from community, from family, from friends, from God but people can always turn around.
Taking our grievance before everyone should be the last step. Even then, it should be a request for everyone‘s help in reconciliation rather than simply looking for others to take our side.
If I may be bold to say so, Christianity is not about taking sides. It is about loving one another and, when differences inevitably arise, to seek and find reconciliation.
God help me to practice what I preach!
______________________
Photo of a stuffed warthog on the main thoroughfare in Warrenton, Virginia. Reflection 2026-13. Photo copyright 2023; text, 2026 by Danny Nelson Schweers.
Danny chairs SsAM’s Communication Committee. He is an active photographer and writer. Click here to visit Danny’s website and make a comment.
See all of Danny’s reflections on this website.
